Received another team set shipment from Neil Hoppenworth on Monday, yay!
While Hoppenworth usually sends just the base sets, or maybe the easiest parallels, every now and then he'll send along a jersey or an autograph. He charges me Beckett High less my ten percent discount, so it's definitely not the best way to collect these cards, but it's always a nice surprise when I find something extra in one of Hoppenworth's boxes. It might be the one time my collecting experience can approximate the thrill of the boxbreaker's pull, so I always drop these cards into my collection gladlly, without worrying too much that I overpaid.
So understand I'm not really bitching about Hoppenworth when I bring up the 2009 Bowman Prospects Auto # BPA-NG that was included in my shipment Monday. And again, I'm always happy to slide an autographed card into my collection. I've got at least 323 of the things, why get picky now?
But isn't it stretching things just a little bit to include Gorneault in a set that you would expect--given the name and all--to include only prospects? Looks like Gorneault has actually had something of a distinguished minor league career, looks like he's shown some power, and some onbase skill, but I mean, the back of the very same card we're talking about says that Gorneault came to the Astros organization as a minor league free agent.
Now, don't get me wrong. Astroland in some ways is a site that celebrates exactly the same kind of player as Nick Gorneault. In the larger scheme of things, there are damn few people who play baseball as well as Nick Gorneault does.
But come on. If Gorneault's former team voluntarily allowed him to walk, then he can't very well be a prospect, can he?
And so--to get this diatribe moving on a tack often taken by collectors elsewhere on the internet--if Gorneault's not a prospect, then why is his card valued by Beckett as if he were?
Taking a look at the 11-card set, I see another player included by the name of Brad Hand. He's a pitcher in the Marlins system, most recently for the Greensboro Grasshoppers. I've certainly never heard of him before, and his numbers look OK, if not earth-shattering. But there is one thing that this Hand character has that Nick Gorneault does not, and that's time to improve. Hand is 19 years old, so if Bowman wants to include him in a Prospects set, the worst thing I could possibly say, even if I hated the guy, is that while he might not be a prospect right now, he still could become one later on.
That's sort of the opposite of the thing we could say about Gorneault, who WAS a prospect, let's say about 2004, but isn't one anymore.
Yet, even though we've pretty much established that Brad Hand and Nick Gorneault are complete opposites in terms of prospecthood, somehow Beckett has their cards listed at the same book value of $12.00.
Meanwhile, The last Gorneault auto to sell on ebay went for 99 cents.
At any rate, just so I'm clear: Although I have some little issue with its very existence, now that it's here, I don't have a problem with putting this card into my books. I don't even have a problem with Neil Hoppenworth charging me Beckett High less 10 for it. But I *do* have a problem with Beckett's having determined their high value for this card as being $12.00. It's more like 4.00.
And of course, I have no problem with Gorneault himself. Though I question his presence in any prospect set, I'm all over any card which shows him in his natural habitat.